7 underrated island getaways

Welcome to Cheapflights

The simple way to find cheap flights and hotels from all your favourite travel companies

If you’ve ever dreamed of staying on a castaway island but rejected the idea as ridiculously expensive, think again. Of course there are tropical private islands that are the sole preserve of billionaires and rock stars, but it is possible to enjoy an authentic Robinson Crusoe experience without the silly price tag. Here, Jane Anderson, Editor of 101 Honeymoons, reveals the most underrated island getaways.

Search for flights to Mauritius


On a warm sunny day, the tiny Channel Island of Herm could easily be mistaken for a tropical castaway spot. Just a mile-and-a-half from end to end and a short ferry ride from Guernsey, there’s a real feeling of escaping real life here.

There’s nothing much to do but look for shells (what else) on Shell Beach and take long leisurely lunches at The Mermaid Tavern. Stay at the splendid White House Hotel or book a self-catering cottage (though be warned, these are highly sought after, so book well in advance).

How to Stay on a Castaway Island: Hern, Channel Islands
Herm by Stephen


The Scottish islands are among the most romantic in the world with white sand beaches and awe-inspiring scenery. McKinlay Kidd is a specialist in the area and its Scottish Island Escape is a week-long adventure combining three islands of the Southern Hebrides – Gigha, Islay and Colonsay.

The company will also give you tips on finding the best secluded beaches and top spots for seal spotting.

How to Stay on a Castaway Island: The Colonsay Hotel, Argyle, Scotland
The Colonsay Hotel, Argyle, Scotland


Croatia has an eye-poppingly beautiful coastline that stretches for 1,000km and is dotted with islands. Try Hotel Bozica on the Elaphiti Island of Sipan – it’s just an hour’s drive from Dubrovnik Old Town with the last leg of the journey by speedboat.

The hotel has just 15 rooms and suites all with fabulous sea views and a private beach.

How to Stay on a Castaway Island: Hotel Bozica, Croatia.
Hotel Bozica.


Ibiza’s quiet little sister, Formentera, is the perfect in-the-know find for those who love the hippy vibe of the White Isle, but want to leave the wild clubbing nights behind them.

Jump on the ferry from Ibiza and you’ll soon be chilling out with a cocktail at sunset, cycling round the island and zoning out with a spot of yoga. The Gecko Beach hotel is as laid back as they come with limewashed furniture, fab Italian food in the restaurant, a beautiful pool and oversized daybeds with shady curtains.

How to Stay on a Castaway Island: Formentera, Balearic Islands
Formentera, one of the heavenly Balearic Islands. Photo: David Vega


Although familiar to British package tourists, the Canary Islands can be surprisingly exotic, not least for their unworldly volcanic landscapes.

Lanzarote has a touch of Brazil about it in the north with beautiful towns like Haria, home to the house and studio of artist Cesar Manrique. Stay in an authentic Mongolian yurt or eco-beach hut at Lanzarote Retreats.

How to Stay on a Castaway Island: Lanzarote, Canary Islands
A Lanzarote sunset. Photo: Tony Hisgett


The volcanic archipelago of the Azores offers beautiful rugged landscapes and emerald green scenery. They are also great value for money. During the summer months you can try whale watching, swimming with dolphins, horse riding, kayaking and surfing.

Whale watching is some of the best in Europe.

How to Stay on a Castaway Island: Azores islands
The Azores. Photo: Feliciano Guimarães


There are no theme parks or tacky resorts in Fort Myers and Sanibel, a beautiful stretch of Florida’s Gulf Coast that boasts 100 islands close to the shoreline.

The focus is firmly on the outdoors, nature and wildlife with nature reserves and strict rules outlaying buildings taller than the highest palm tree.

Sanibel and Captiva are the largest of the islands. The smaller islands such as North Captiva, Useppa and Cayo Costa are very exclusive.

How to Stay on a Castaway Island: Sanibel, Florida
Sanibel, Florida
Search for flights to Sri Lanka
7 underrated island getaways was last modified: June 27th, 2019 by Oonagh Shiel
Author: Oonagh Shiel (20 posts)

Content Manager at Cheapflights whose travel life can be best summed up as BC (before children) and PC (post children). We only travel during the school holidays so short-haul trips and staycations are our specialities!